The Evolution of Warfare, the Laws of War, and the Ethical Implications of U.S. Detainee Policy in the Global War on Terror and Beyond, June 2006

Background

Extract from the thesis:

The atrocities committed by American GIs at Abu Ghraib shocked the collective moral conscience of the U.S. Guilty of inhumane treatment of its prisoners there, Abu Ghraib did immeasurable damage to America’s international credibility and made clear that American detainee policy is off-track and needs to be corrected to comply with objective standards of law, morality, and operational effectiveness. The shock and emotional aftermath of 9/11 created a politically permissive environment within which the bureaucratic and organizational structures of the military were unsuited for the critical tasks assigned to them relative to the context of the Bush Administration’s “new paradigm.”

Two issues sit at the forefront of the political and socio-cultural context of U.S. detainee policy: war powers and human rights. This thesis will utilize a synthesized decision-making model to analyze the President’s decisions leading to the current detainee policy. Potential policy alternatives require smaller corrections to bureaucratic process rather than requiring a major reorganization of bureaucratic structure.

Continue scrolling for more...

This thesis will provide policy-makers with a moral and legal framework for the categorization and treatment of enemy prisoners. Adoption of the full framework of the 1949 Geneva Conventions, including U.S. ratification of Additional Protocols I and II (1977), provides the best available framework to combat transnational insurgency, while retaining the moral and legal high ground required of the world’s champion of liberal democracy.

Document Archive

 The Evolution of Warfare, the Laws of War, and the Ethical Implications of U.S. Detainee Policy in the Global War on Terror and Beyond, June 2006 [140 Pages, 1.9MB]

https://documents.theblackvault.com/documents/navy/SheieThesis.pdf

Follow The Black Vault on Social Media:

This post was published on July 11, 2017 11:46 pm

John Greenewald

Recent Posts

Future Battlefield Energy: 2009 DIA Report Examines Nonconventional Power Sources for U.S. Troops

A document released from the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA), obtained under the Freedom of Information…

May 19, 2025

FBI Files: Historical Figures & Groups

Background Welcome to the FBI Files on Historical Figures & Groups archive at The Black…

May 19, 2025

FBI Files: American Military

Welcome to the FBI Files on American Military Personnel archive at The Black Vault. This…

May 13, 2025

From AATIP to NPSMS: The Mystery Continues To Deepen

This article was originally published June 5, 2024. It was updated on May 7, 2025,…

May 7, 2025

DHS Briefing Details Select Drone Sightings in New Jersey, Highlights Potential Misidentifications Among 5,000+ Reports

Following a surge of more than 5,000 drone sighting reports in New Jersey in late…

May 5, 2025

The Robert F. Kennedy Assassination Records Archive

(Click here to jump directly to the search engine) In January 2025, President Donald J.…

April 28, 2025