• Home
    • Document Archive
    • Case File Database
    • Discussion Forums
  • FOIA Documents
    • Government
      • Congressional & Senatorial Correspondence
      • Controversies
        • Conspiracy Discussion Forum
      • Elections
      • Government Accountability & I.G. Reports
      • Government Employee Manuals / Orientation
      • Politician Public Financial Disclosure Statements
      • TV Show Complaints
      • U.S. Financial Information
      • U.S. Politics Discussion Forum
      • Discussion Forums
    • History
      • Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) Collection
      • Department of Defense Collection
      • Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Collection
      • J.F.K. Era
      • National Security Agency (NSA) Collection
      • Office of Technology Assessment Collection
      • Richard Helms Collection
      • Discussion Forums
    • Intelligence
      • Cryptology
      • FBI Files / Domestic & Foreign Intelligence
      • Field Manuals
      • Freedom of Information Act / Research Tools
      • Spy Satellites and the NRO
      • Discussion Forums
    • Military / Defense
      • Advanced “For Its Time” Technology
      • Aircraft / Air Force History
        • Bombers
        • Cargo
        • E”X”perimental
        • Fighters
        • Foreign
        • Reconnaissance
        • Spy Planes
        • Stealth
      • Biological / Chemical Weapons
      • Defense Issues
      • Military and Commercial Accidents
      • Nuclear Weapons
      • Psychological Operations
      • Terrorism
        • Assassination Attempts
        • September 11th, 2001
      • Weapons
      • Discussion Forums
    • Science
      • Disease and Human Health
      • Environmental Issues
      • Space
      • Discussion Forums
    • The Fringe
      • Cloning
      • Mind Control
      • New World Order
      • Parapsychology
      • Remote Viewing
      • UFO Phenomena
        • UFO Discussion Forum
      • Weather / Weather Modification
      • Discussion Forums
    • Wartime
      • World War I
      • World War II
      • Vietnam Era
      • Cold War Era
      • Iraq Wars
      • Afghanistan War
      • War on Terror Discussion Forum
  • Paranormal Case Files
  • Chat
    • Facebook Group
    • Discord Server
  • Podcast
  • Contact
    • Update Newsletter
  • Shop
    • Books
    • T-Shirts
    • Account details
  • Donate
Facebook Twitter YouTube
Trending
  • Evaluation of the Oversight of Intelligence Interrogation Approaches and Techniques (DODIG-2019-077)
  • Operation Earnest Voice
  • New UAP Leaked Imagery from the DoD: “Mosul Orb” UAP Published by Jeremy Corbell & George Knapp
  • The Black Vault’s AAWSAP/AATIP and Post 2017 UAP/UFO Timeline Project
  • “They’re Back!”: FAA Air Traffic Control Audio Released of UFO Sightings by Multiple Aircraft – 11/11/22
  • DARPA Selects Aurora Flight Sciences for Phase 2 of Active Flow Control X-Plane
  • Range Fouler Debrief Forms and Reports
  • U.S. Government Releases 2nd UAP / UFO Report to the Public
Facebook Twitter YouTube Instagram TikTok Discord
The Black Vault
  • Home
    • Document Archive
    • Case File Database
    • Discussion Forums
  • FOIA Documents
    • Government
      • Congressional & Senatorial Correspondence
      • Controversies
        • Conspiracy Discussion Forum
      • Elections
      • Government Accountability & I.G. Reports
      • Government Employee Manuals / Orientation
      • Politician Public Financial Disclosure Statements
      • TV Show Complaints
      • U.S. Financial Information
      • U.S. Politics Discussion Forum
      • Discussion Forums
    • History
      • Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) Collection
      • Department of Defense Collection
      • Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Collection
      • J.F.K. Era
      • National Security Agency (NSA) Collection
      • Office of Technology Assessment Collection
      • Richard Helms Collection
      • Discussion Forums
    • Intelligence
      • Cryptology
      • FBI Files / Domestic & Foreign Intelligence
      • Field Manuals
      • Freedom of Information Act / Research Tools
      • Spy Satellites and the NRO
      • Discussion Forums
    • Military / Defense
      • Advanced “For Its Time” Technology
      • Aircraft / Air Force History
        • Bombers
        • Cargo
        • E”X”perimental
        • Fighters
        • Foreign
        • Reconnaissance
        • Spy Planes
        • Stealth
      • Biological / Chemical Weapons
      • Defense Issues
      • Military and Commercial Accidents
      • Nuclear Weapons
      • Psychological Operations
      • Terrorism
        • Assassination Attempts
        • September 11th, 2001
      • Weapons
      • Discussion Forums
    • Science
      • Disease and Human Health
      • Environmental Issues
      • Space
      • Discussion Forums
    • The Fringe
      • Cloning
      • Mind Control
      • New World Order
      • Parapsychology
      • Remote Viewing
      • UFO Phenomena
        • UFO Discussion Forum
      • Weather / Weather Modification
      • Discussion Forums
    • Wartime
      • World War I
      • World War II
      • Vietnam Era
      • Cold War Era
      • Iraq Wars
      • Afghanistan War
      • War on Terror Discussion Forum
  • Paranormal Case Files
  • Chat
    • Facebook Group
    • Discord Server
  • Podcast
  • Contact
    • Update Newsletter
  • Shop
    • Books
    • T-Shirts
    • Account details
  • Donate
0 Shopping Cart
The Black Vault
Home » Intelligence » A Special Inquiry Regarding the Accuracy of FBI Statements Concerning its Capabilities to Exploit an iPhone Seized During the San Bernardino Terror Attack Investigation, March 2018
FBI Files / Domestic & Foreign Intelligence

A Special Inquiry Regarding the Accuracy of FBI Statements Concerning its Capabilities to Exploit an iPhone Seized During the San Bernardino Terror Attack Investigation, March 2018

John GreenewaldBy John GreenewaldApril 4, 20183 Mins Read

Background

According to the document:

“On December 2, 2015, a terror attack in San Bernardino, California killed 14 people and injured 17 others. The next day, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) seized pursuant to a search warrant the iPhone of one of the subjects believed to have been responsible for the attack, Syed Rizwan Farook. Thereafter, on February 9 and March 1, 2016, then-FBI Director James Comey testified before Congress, in substance, that the FBI was not able to obtain access to data on the Farook iPhone, and then that it would require assistance from the manufacturer, Apple, to do so. To accomplish this, on February 16, 2016, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California (USAO) sought and obtained an ex parte court order requiring Apple to assist the FBI in its effort to search the iPhone.

A few days later, the USAO filed a motion with the Court seeking to compel Apple’s compliance with the ex parte order, and Apple filed a motion to vacate the order. However, on March 21, 2016, before the District Judge ruled on these pending motions, the USAO reported to the Court that an outside party had  demonstrated to the FBI a possible method for unlocking the iPhone. One week later, on March 28, 2016, the USAO reported back to the Court that the FBI had successfully accessed the iPhone and no longer required assistance from Apple. On April 19, 2016, then- FBI Executive Assistant Director (EAD) Amy Hess testified about the matter before Congress and cited rapidly changing technology as a reason the FBI was not able to exploit the iPhone without the assistance of a third party.

On August 31, 2016, the Office of the Inspector General (OIG) received a referral from the FBI Inspection Division after former EAD Hess expressed concern about an alleged disagreement between units within the FBI Operational Technology Division (OTD) over the “capabilities available to the national security programs” to access the Farook iPhone following its seizure, and concerns that this may have resulted in her or Comey giving inaccurate testimony to Congress on the FBI’s capabilities. Specifically, EAD Hess expressed concerns that an OTD unit may have had techniques available to exploit the Farook iPhone that certain unidentified OTD officials did not employ and that these officials were indifferent to the fact that FBI leadership and others were testifying to Congress, and filing affidavits in court, that the FBI had no such capability. The OIG has conducted inquiries into the situation, including interviewing relevant key participants, and found no evidence that OTO had the capability to exploit the Farook iPhone at the time of the Congressional testimony and initial court filings. We therefore determined that neither the Congressional testimony nor the submissions to the Court were inaccurate when made. However, we found that inadequate communication and coordination within OTO caused a delay in engaging all relevant OTO personnel in t he search for a technical solution to the Farook iPhone problem, as well as the outside party that ultimately developed the method that unlocked the phone, issues that we learned the FBI has since taken steps to address.”

Document Archive

 A Special Inquiry Regarding the Accuracy of FBI Statements Concerning its Capabilities to Exploit an iPhone Seized During the San Bernardino Terror Attack Investigation, March 2018 [17 Pages, 2.5MB]

https://documents.theblackvault.com/documents/fbifiles/o1803.pdf

Follow The Black Vault on Social Media:
  • Facebook
  • Facebook Group
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • iTunes Podcasts
  • Patreon
  • Discord
  • Mastodon
  • TikTok
  • Parler
facebookShare on Facebook
TwitterTweet
FBI Federal Bureau of Investigation Office of the Inspector General OIG

Related Posts

FBI Files: American Politicians, Aides, and Appointees

January 3, 2023

FOIA & MDR Case Logs

December 23, 2022

FBI Files: Television Networks

November 28, 2022

Comments are closed.

Shop
  • The Black Vault UFO Design #1 $17.99 – $21.99
Search The Black Vault
Subscribe to the Mailing List




Help Make This Site Possible

Can you help support The Black Vault?

For as little as $1 a month, you not only help this site IMMENSELY, but you get some exclusive stuff in the process!

Become a Patron!


Or, a One Time Donation option is also available:
FOIA Document Categories
  • Government
    • Congressional & Senatorial Correspondence
    • Controversies
    • Elections
    • Government Accountability & I.G. Reports
    • Government Employee Manuals / Orientation
    • Politician Public Financial Disclosure Statements
    • TV Show Complaints
    • U.S. Financial Information
  • History
    • Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) Collection
    • Department of Defense Collection
    • Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Collection
    • J.F.K. Era
    • National Security Agency (NSA) Collection
    • Office of Technology Assessment Collection
    • Richard Helms Collection
  • Intelligence
    • Cryptology
    • FBI Files / Domestic & Foreign Intelligence
    • Field Manuals
    • Freedom of Information Act / Research Tools
    • Spy Satellites and the NRO
  • Military / Defense
    • Advanced "For Its Time" Technology
    • Aircraft / Air Force History
      • Bombers
      • Cargo
      • E"X"perimental
      • Fighters
      • Foreign
      • Reconnaissance
      • Spy Planes
      • Stealth
      • Unconfirmed
    • Biological / Chemical Weapons
    • Defense Issues
    • Military and Commercial Accidents
    • Nuclear Weapons
    • Psychological Operations
    • Terrorism
      • Assassination Attempts
      • September 11th, 2001
    • Weapons
  • Science
    • Disease and Human Health
    • Environmental Issues
    • Space
    • Weather / Weather Modification
  • The Fringe
    • Cloning
    • Mind Control
    • New World Order
    • Parapsychology
    • Remote Viewing
    • UFO Phenomena
  • Uncategorized
  • Wartime
    • Afghanistan War
    • Cold War Era
    • Iraq Wars
    • Vietnam Era
    • World War I
    • World War II
The Black Vault Radio
bvr

  • Ep. #116 – Alejandro Rojas on the Current UFO Conversation; The Science of UFOs; UAP Data; UFO Congress; and More (10/08/22)
  • Ep. #115 – The CIA, UFOs and “Material” (9/30/22)
  • Ep. #114 – Bruce Fenton on Interstellar Objects and Technosignatures (9/22/22)
  • Ep. #113 – DoD Refuses To Release Key Documents On UFO Office; Cites National Security Interest (9/22/22)
  • Ep. #112 – U.S. Navy Says ALL UAP/UFO Videos Are Classified And Exempt From Release (9/18/22)
  • Ep. #111 – Is UFO Secrecy Deepening? Here’s why I say yes… (9/17/22)
  • Ep. #110 – Chris Rutkowski on Canada’s UFOs, Government UFO Consultation and Nearly Five Decades of Research (9/7/22)
  • Ep. #109 – The Reaction to My Deep Dive Into Luis Elizondo’s IG Complaint (8/30/22)
  • Ep. #108 – Deep Dive into Luis Elizondo’s DoD Inspector General Complaint (8/26/22)
  • Ep. #107 – The “Hottel Memo” Finally Revealed IN FULL – So What’s it Say?! (8/9/22)
  • Ep. #106 – Grant Lavac on the UFO/UAP Issue in Australia (7/23/22)
  • Ep. #105 – Exploring the DoD’s NEW “All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office” (7/20/22)
  • Ep. #104 – Randall Nickerson on the Ariel Phenomenon (6/10/22)
  • Ep. #103 – The UAP Hearing: Highlights & Commentary – May 25, 2022 (5/25/22)
  • Ep. #102 – Congressional Hearing on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAP) – May 17, 2022 (5/18/22)
  • Ep. #101 – Congressional Hearing on UFOs - Some Thoughts Before It All Goes Down (5/16/22)
  • MORE EPISODES

Facebook Twitter YouTube Instagram TikTok Discord
© 2023 The Black Vault, Inc.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.